Largely confirmed — but count-dependent and smaller than conventional wisdom suggests.
The advantage holds in
11 of 12 counts, but the effect size varies significantly.
The biggest edges appear at
3-0 (+1.7 pts),
3-2 (+1.4 pts), and
0-2 (+1.2 pts) —
the counts where pitchers are most forced into predictable behavior (must throw a strike, or trying to expand the zone).
In neutral counts like
1-1 and 2-1, where pitchers have more flexibility, the advantage nearly disappears.
This pattern points to
pitcher behavior under pressure as the driver,
more than batter ability to read spin.